|
|
BGRA Feature: Matt's String Reviews
|
Strings, Strings, and More Strings
by Matt Schmill
last update: 4/23/2004
|
Since I've started making my own basses, I've
had a chance to get to know a few different strings. It's hard to
remember one pack from the next without writing stuff down; I dare you
to look at a product list from one of the major
manufacturers. Hex-core, round-core, ribbon-wound,
compression-wound. How do you decide what's important and what's not?
The prices listed here are approximate at the time of posting, and
reflect typical cost at an online string retailer. The prices may be
ancient, as I wrote some of these mini-reviews agest ago! Your local
experience may vary, but they'll give you an idea of how one string
price compares to the next.
My Favorites:
For fretless: TI Jazz Flats
For slap bass: DR Hi Beams
For fingerstyle: La Bella Deep Talkin' Bass
Best nickelwound: DR Sunbeams
Best cheap-ass string: SIT Silencers
Overall best roundwound: DR Hi Beams
|
General Recommendations
The two main distinctions to be made among strings are materials and
winding. Most major manufacturers make a stainless steel string and
nickel-plated steel string. The most common winding is a roundwound,
but some manufacturers make flatwound strings, some make a
groundwound, and one of the newer strings to hit the market is the
compression wound string. All these windings refer to how the string
is made: strings consist of a core, and a wrap (or "winding"). As the
name suggests, roundwounds have a round wrap, flatwounds have a
ribbon-like wrap, groundwounds have round windings that are ground
down, and compression wound strings are rounds wound under compression
that takes some of the bite out of the string.
You will notice a marked difference in the sound and feel of these
different types of strings. Steel strings have a super-metallic sound,
while a nickel plating will mellow that clang of the steel out
some. Steels are also somewhat rougher feeling than
nickels. Roundwounds have by far the best high end
brilliance. Flatwounds have an almost "dead", thuddy sound right out
of the box. Grounds are like flats with some brightness. Compression
wound strings are smooth-feeling rounds with just a bit of the
brightness taken out. Roundwounds collect dirt and oils in the ridges
and eventually that kills the brightness of the strings, causing them
to go "dead". Flats and rounds stay consistent in terms of tone for a
long, long time.
|
|
Between feel, tone, and such, I have come to feel that
nickel-plated rounds are my favorite for fingerstyle and all-around
play on a fretted bass. For slap, I believe stainless strings cannot
be beat. I prefer groundwound or flatwound on a fretless for the
warmth and the feel, though those wanting some high-end bite should
consider compression wound strings as a nice alternative. My favorite
strings for different situations are listed at left. Your mileage may,
of course, vary. The best policy is exploration, if you can afford
it. Use these summaries to give you a rough idea of where you might
want to go next, and take a shot. Chances are, after 2 or 3 sets,
you'll find one you really like.
Before we get to the mini-reviews, let me just give a word of
caution in regard to winding length. Two things you'd like to avoid
are wrapping the winding of thick strings around the tuner post and
running the silk of some string over the nut. The fat strings may have
more than one winding around the core. Generally these strings have
tapered windings on the non-ball end of the string so you can fit the
string into your tuner post. Often the tapered part is wrapped in
silk. You do not want the fattest part wound around the tuner if you
can help it. Likewise, you generally do not want the silk to run over
the nut. The key here is buying a set of strings that fits your
bass. Nowadays, basses are available with many different scale
lengths. The traditional scale length is 34". This is considered by
most manufacturers to be "long" scale, short scale is considered 30",
and medium scale is 32". 35" and 36" are considered "extra-long". So,
even though your 35" scale bass was sold to you as a long-scale bass,
GHS and D'Addarrio longs are usually not long enough! If you
string through the body, they will be shorter still. I've also found
that DR makes a string that will fit most 34" and 35" scale
basses. That's pretty smart, eh? The new Everly strings fit my
string-through-the-body 34" scale 4 string, so I think they'll fit
most 34" and 35" scale basses, too. Best thing to do is to look on the
manufacturer's web site for winding lengths, or better yet, buy local
and bring your bass. Make sure they'll fit!
|
Carvin
$45 (for 3 6-string sets) (only available direct) |
How good is this
price? Pretty average nickel roundwounds, these come in one
guage: 128, 100, 80, 60, 40, 29. I found these strings to be
reasonably snappy out of the package, but somewhat flabby
sounding and lacking the slick feel that some of the other
strings seem to have. Life expectency is somewhat short. In a
pinch, though, these strings aren't bad, and are the most
inexpensive I've seen. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
75% 80% 95% 70% |
Conklin Snakeskins
$40 (for 7-string set)
|
If you have a 7
string bass, this set of strings is the one you should
buy. They have a wound F string, which is all you need to
know.
These are custom guage steel rounds that I would guess are
made by La Bella. The 94% rating for "feel" is simply because
of the wound F string. It is far superior to a plain F
string. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
88% 94% 80% 88% |
D'addario Chromes $38 (5 string set) |
I finally have gotten a chance to check these strings out on one of my
own basses. My initial impression is that first of all, flats or
grounds are a must-have for people who own at least one fretless and
one fretted. They sound cool and uprighty, and they definately feel
cool, in addition to not chewing up fingerboards like roundwounds.
So, I like the Chromes. In fact, I think they stack up nicely against
the Thomastik Jazz Flats, which are more expensive. The Chromes seem
to be higher tension than the Thomastiks. Not much, but somewhat
tighter. This is a double edged sword, as looser can be faster, but
tighter is, well.... tighter. Overall, I would say that given the
price tags, I lean towards the Chromes over the Thomastiks.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
85% 85% 70% ??? |
D'addario XL170 $15 (4 string set) |
I put these on a
fretless at the request of it's buyer. The pack I tried were
"soft guage", which were .100's. They are nickel
roundwounds. No roundwound has ever really thrilled me on a
fretless, but these really perked the bass up. For that bass,
I think they were perfect. They played real smooth (I love
those 100's) and has a nice, sweet sound. A solid nickel
string. I've since tried the XL170 5 string set, which have a
pretty solid low B. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
85% 88% 88% 80% |
D'addario Slowounds $20 (4 string set) |
I bought the
Slowwounds to put on a customer's bass a couple of months
ago. When that fell through, they sat for a while. Well, I
finally finished up a 33" scale 4 string bass, and I decided
what the heck, I'll put them on it.
Now, somehow, I decided to string this thing B-E-A-D. Yeah, a
33" scale bass with a B. People complain about floppy B
strings on a 34" scale bass, and I go and put one on a short
scale. Well, the good news is that the B string is not flabby,
though it is not perfect. In fact, this set (I can't remember
what guage we're talking about) seems pretty tight.
That aside, I don't notice much difference in the Slowound
strings from other D'Addarrio nickels. They feel nice, and
sound good, too. But that's $5 a set you could be
spending on beer or sandwiches if you bought XL170's instead...
update, 7/4/2001
I decided to try another set of Slowounds today, this time a 6 string set on a 35" scale bass. I have the "Long Scale" set and it does not fit. The silk starts a good 1/2" before the nut, when strung on an ABM quick load bridge. This is very disappointing, as I think few people consider a 34" scale bass "long scale", especially for a 6 string set. Now I'm stuck with a 6 string set that is only good for 34" scale bass.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
88% 90% 80% 87% |
Dean Markley Blue
Steel $21.40 (4 string set) |
I didn't like
these strings at first. They are dull and grey looking, with a
sort of coarse feel to them, like most steels. But after
getting a set of Ken Smith Rock Masters, I became a steel
believer, and I put this set on one of my fretted basses, and
I like them a lot now. The Rock Masters are cheaper, though,
so I still like them a bit better. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
90% 85% 80% 90% |
DR Hi-Beams $20.25 (4 string set) |
I finally broke
down and sprung for the extra $5 it cost me to get DRs instead
of Ken Smith or D'addarrio. I got the Hi-Beam 100's, which are
stainless steel roundwounds. I believe they have a
round core. These strings just feel better than any other
steel string I have played. The sound is snappy and tight. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
93% 95% 85% 90% |
DR Lo Riders $20.25 (4 string set) |
If you're like me,
you're wondering what the difference between Hi Beams and Lo Riders
is. If you're like me, you went out and bought both to find out, and
you made sure to get stainless Lo Riders so it would be a real
apples-and-apples comparison. Technically, the Lo Riders have a hex
core, and Hi Beams have a round core. Apparently, the Lo Riders are a
little less bright looking. They look a lot like the Ken Smith Rock
Masters. They feel just like Hi Beams, and are great for slap
bass. Just great. The difference is slight between the two
strings (at least the steel versions), but I would have to say
that the low riders are less bright and sparkling. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
93% 93% 85% 92% |
DR Sunbeams $29.70 (5 string set) |
I like the DR
steel strings so much, I decided, "what the heck, I might as
well try some of their nickel strings. The Sunbeams are those
strings. I got a .125-.45 5 string set of Sunbeams to go on a
35" scale bass I made. They fit the bass perfectly, but on a
shorter scale bass, you'd end up wrapping the windings, I
think. I'm going to start putting up winding lengths soon.
Anyway, I think I like the feel of nickel strings better, in
general, than even the good steel strings. I like the
slickness of the sun beams. They slap pretty good, and I am
starting to think that the D'Addarrio XL170's don't do that as
well. All around, Sunbeams are at the top of my nickel
list. They feel and sound great, and slap better than the
XL170's.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
91% 97% 88% 90% |
Ernie Ball Slinky $19.00 (5 string set) |
Hey, get this. Someone sent me an email raving about Ernie Ball Slinkys and I actually went out and bought a set to review. Go figure.
At first, I thought these were nothing special. Just between you and me, most strings are nothing special. In fact, I thought, "who cares?"
The other night, though, I finally brought the bass I put them on into the recording room. They actually play pretty nice. They're not overly bright, which is fine for me on a 5 string, since I generally do not do funky slap stuff on anything other than a 4 anyways. So, for me, feel is the big thing on a 5 string. And these feel pretty good.
Bottom line: do not fear buying Slinkys. They feel good. Not real bright. Good value.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
86% 92% 95% NA |
Everly Bass Rockers $11.95 (4 string set) |
I got these Everly strings because they're so darn
cheap. Changing strings every couple weeks at $20-25 is not in
most people's budgets. At $12, now we're getting into the
realm of possibility.
As you might have guessed, these are very run-of-the-mill nickel
roundwounds. Is that the good news, or the bad news? Well,
it's good news, I think, if you're the type that buys whatever
nickel strings are on sale -- D'Addarrio or Charlie Stringers
or whatever. The Bass Rockers certainly feel okay, and sound
fine unamplified. The guage is very regular -- 100, 80, 60,
40.
I guess it's bad news if you are a die-hard for a particular
brand, especially if you pay a lot to get a particular
brand. This is because the Everly strings don't have any
particular strength besides their price. If you are a DR
die-hard, the Everly strings won't change your mind. If you
aren't, though, the $2-3 savings per pack over the closest
competitor might win you over.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
84% 88% 96% 88% |
Everly B-52 Rockers |
After reading my Rockers review, an Everly rep sent me these
strings. He said that the Rockers I reviewed must have been an
old set, and he wanted me to get the real deal to
review. Sounded good to me, so the first 4 string to come out
of the shop got a new set of B-52 Rockers.
The package says these are made of "... a specially magnetic
alloy called Alloy-52 ... that is incredibly resonant and
tarnish resistant." Looks and feels like well polished nickel
winding to me.
The B-52 strings sound good to my ear out of the box. Even
sound from E-G, with the bright, lively sound that you should
expect from a new nickel roundwound. A nice slapping
string. Feel is good, not coarse, but not as slick and smooth
as some strings I have played. I like these strings, both in
terms of feel and sound, than the Bass Rockers I tried.
These strings seem to come in at around $4-5 cheaper than DR
strings, although I am basing this on pricing I have seen on a
string called "Everly Bass Sessions", which is an Alloy 52
roundwound. The B-52 Rockers could be another string
altogether, but pricing on Everly strings is all around darn
good. If you're looking to cut budget on strings, take a look
at Everyly B-52's.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
90% 88% 94% ?? |
GHS Bass
Boomers $19 (4 string set) |
I've never really
been impressed by Bass Boomers. They are snappy, I guess, like
most nickel-plated strings, but there's really nothing about them
that distinguishes them from any other string, and the price
is just okay. I've tried Mediums and Lights of this brand. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
85% 85% 80% 80% |
GHS Brite Flats
$19.70 (4 string set) +$3.50 hi c string |
It ain't easy
finding a flatwound set with a hi C if that's the way you like to
string your fretless 5 string. After about a month with XL170's on
mine, I finally found the GHS Brite Flats - with a hi C
string. They're ground roundwounds, so they're not actually
flatwounds, but they are smooth! I love the feel, and they actually
are pretty bright sounding. Much brighter than the D'Addarrio Chromes,
which have their own appeal, but also much cheaper. I like these
strings! |
Sound Feel Value Life |
90% 95% 95% 95% |
Ken Smith Rock
Masters $16.25 (4 string set, retail) |
When I bought these, I hadn't realized that were stainless steel. After my unspectacular initial experience with the Blue Steel strings, I was a little disappointed. I strung them on my freshly finished four string fretted and was pleasantly surprised. These have a pretty slick feel to them, and have a very crisp, snappy tone. The medium-light (.100-.45) gauge is right-on for me. Suddenly, I'm a believer in steel strings. The judge is still out on durability, but so far, so good. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
90% 88% 85% 85% |
Ken Smith
Tapercore 7 string set $30.25 (7 string set) |
I bought these
strings to put on a fretless 6 string I was building, that I
wanted to string E-F (tenor). Well, I finally finished the
bass. These strings are just like Rock Masters, as far as I
can tell, except for the taper at the ball end. The taper on
the E string continues past the saddle on my ABM bridge. I
dunno if that's the way they're supposed to go, or if the ABM
is just a "short" bridge. At any rate, the C and F strings on
this set (a .028 and a .020) are quite thin, while the lower
strings (E, A, D) are pretty gutsy. I can imagine the F
string being only useful in chords, or in a very controlled
environment (i.e. a studio). Probably not Ken Smith's
fault. What do you expect out of a 28 and a 20? |
Sound Feel Value Life Balance |
82% 86% 85% 88% 60% |
La Bella "Deep
Talkin' Bass" $16.95 (4 string set) |
Cool name, right?
Check this out: the subtitle is "perfectly balanced set". What
this boils down to is that instead of a .100 or a .105, they
give you a .102. My set is Med-lt: .102, .077, .058,
.039, stainless steel. Can you really tell the difference
between a .102 and a .100? Probably not. These strings do
sound nice, producing a surprisingly huge sound out of a set
of Bartolini 9J (jazz pickups). And I do like the
guage.... but I like .100's, too, and most people won't feel
much difference (myself included). No reason not to buy them,
though, they're good strings, and if you happen to feel like
.105's are too tight and .100's are too floppy, these are the
ones for you. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
92% 88% 88% 91% |
La Bella
"Slappers (6 string)" $26.95 (6 string set) |
I like La Bella
strings. As I understand, they can be a pain to deal with and
get strings from. Too bad.
These are nickel rounds. Very slick feeling, great playing
strings. Good life to them, nice sound. Unfortunately, these
are on a 6 string fretless (not my idea), so I couldn't really
get them slapping to put their name to the test. Definately in
the same league as Sunbeams, my favorite roundwounds. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
89% 94% 88% 92% |
SIT Silencers
??
|
SIT is a relatively new string company that popped up only a few years ago. Their strings are competitively priced and so I ordered a big batch to try. Among them were Power Wounds, Power Steels, and this set, their "Silencers".
The Silencer is basically SIT's pressurewound string. All their strings come out of the packaging well polished and feeling nice and crisp. The Silencers are quite smooth to the feel, and I used these for a while on fretless basses for people who wanted something close to the bite of a roundwound. These strings somehow manage to feel tight even compared to rounds of a similar guage. SITs are great strings for the price.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
85% 90% 95% 85% |
Snarling Dogs $15 (4 string set) |
Come on, who can
resist a pack of strings that retail for $15 ? It's pretty sad,
considering guitarists get away with $6 sets of strings (for
the expensive ones). These are your run-of-the-mill nickel
roundwounds. The pack I tried were .95-.40 (light
guage). These strings have decent, snappy tone, with a
somewhat coarse feel to them. I don't think I like this light
a gauge, as they can get somewhat flabby sounding. Overall,
though, a good value if you don't feel like spending $30 a pop
for strings, although I prefer the feel of soft guage XL170's. |
Sound Feel Value Life |
80% 78% 90% 75% |
Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Electric Roundwounds $42.50 (5 string set) |
Compared to the DR strings that the bass previously wore the
Thomastiks have much lower string tension, resulting in a soft, easy
playing feel, although the softness does add a bit of looseness to the
B string. Despite this, the B string still sounded nice and clear
right up the neck. These strings are light: .118, .089, .068, .051,
.043.
The sound of these strings was a bit of a surprise- they add a bunch of mids
to the tone; very growly sounding. I will try these on a fretless bass next,
as they seem to be well suited for that. The highs are less shimmering than
the DRs. The bottom is full and tight.
A word of caution- do not attempt to use these on a 35" scale bass, or a
bass with through body stringing! On the 34" scale test
bass the silk windings cleared the zero fret by about 1/2". The 4 string set
is available in super long scale, but apparently not the 5
string set.
(special guest review by Jack Read using a Read Custom 5 string)
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
90% 95% 70% 95% |
Thomastik-Infeld
Jazz Flats $31.95 (4 string set) |
I've heard a lot of good things about Thomastik-Infeld strings
lately, so when I decided to produce a fretless 4 string, I
decided to throw some TI Jazz Flats on it. You know, give them
a ride. The $31.95 price tag is hefty. Are they worth it?
When I first threw them on, I was unimpressed. I was expecting
magic strings -- gleaming chromium superstrings that melt in
my hands. They weren't gleaming chromium, and that
disappointed me. In fact, they are dull-looking flats that are
visibly indistinguishable from most other flats.
After playing them for a while, I like the feel of them. It's
a slightly weird guage -- .043 .056 .070 .100 -- but I think
that may be why they feel good. The guage determines how much
tension you need on the string to tune it to pitch, and so by
tweaking the guages, you can get a more consistent feel from
string to string, and a softer overall feel, which the Jazz
Flats have.
I can't decide whether or not I like these better than the GHS
Brite Flats. They are less bright (not surprisingly) than the
Brite Flats, which on a fretless, has its allure. They also
feel different -- they almost feel less bright, which also has
its appeal. In some ways, they sound and feel more like a
fretless to me.
|
Sound Feel Value Life |
92% 92% 80% 95% |
|